SubstitutePlans.com · Teacher phone guide
Show, Don't Tell: Rewriting Emotion Statements as Scenes
Teacher directions only. Student worksheets and the answer key are in the complete teacher PDF. This downloaded guide opens offline.
SubstitutePlans.com
English Language Arts • Creative Writing
SP-CWRIT-009 • Free to print and use in your classroom • substituteplans.com
Show, Don't Tell: Rewriting Emotion Statements as Scenes
English Language Arts • Creative Writing • Grades 8-11 • 45 minutes
Time needed: 45 minutes (one class period)
Prep: Copy the 2-page worksheet (one per student).
Technology: None.
Student independence: High. Individual writing with an optional pair swap.
Copies to make: One 2-page worksheet per student
Materials: Pencils, Worksheet
Goal for today: Students will distinguish telling statements from showing details, identify the four tools of showing (action, body, dialogue, setting), and rewrite flat emotion statements as short scenes.
BEFORE THE BELL
☐ Copy the worksheet, one per student (2 pages).
☐ Write on the board: TELLING names the feeling (She was nervous). SHOWING gives the evidence (She checked the clock for the third time in a minute).
☐ Write the four tools: ACTION, BODY, DIALOGUE, SETTING.
SAY THIS TO START
Here is a rule good writers break on purpose and bad writers break by accident: do not tell the reader the feeling, show the evidence and let the reader feel it. Today you will learn four tools for showing, catch the telling in a paragraph, and rewrite six flat sentences into scenes.
RUN OF SHOW
0–5 min - YOU: Take attendance. Hand out the worksheet and read the two examples on the board.
STUDENTS: Follow along.
5–12 min - YOU: Students read the explanation on page 1. Ask for a volunteer to show "bored" using one of the four tools without saying the word.
STUDENTS: Read; try one example aloud.
12–22 min - YOU: Students complete Part A (find the telling).
STUDENTS: Mark and label telling sentences.
22–40 min - YOU: Students complete Part B (six rewrites). Walk the room; push students who sneak the emotion word back in.
STUDENTS: Rewrite each statement as a mini-scene.
40–44 min - YOU: Optional: pairs swap and guess the emotion behind each rewrite without seeing the original.
STUDENTS: Swap and guess.
44–45 min - YOU: Collect worksheets.
STUDENTS: Hand in the worksheet.
IF THINGS GO WRONG
• If students use the emotion word in the rewrite, circle it and ask them to replace it with one of the four tools.
• If a student says showing takes too many words, agree: it does, and that is why you save it for the moments that matter.
• If a student finishes early, use the early finisher list.
EARLY FINISHERS
• Rewrite the whole Part A paragraph so that it tells nothing and shows everything.
• Pick one rewrite from Part B and extend it to a full page in your notebook.
SUPPORT AND CHALLENGE
• Support: Let students do four of the six rewrites and allow one emotion word in Part A rather than requiring a full rewrite.
• Challenge: Ask students to do each rewrite in Part B with a different one of the four tools, labeling which tool they used.
NOTES FOR THE TEACHER (you fill this in)
How far the class got / what to pick up next:
Students who were especially helpful:
Anything the teacher should know:
The complete PDF has the student worksheet (pages 4-5) and the answer key (page 6).