English Language Arts English 9-12

Unreliable Narrators: Can You Trust “The Night Shift”?

Students read a short original story told by an overnight gas station clerk who insists his shift went perfectly. They track the clues that prove otherwise, answer 11 questions and retell one moment from another character's point of view.

Grades 9-1250 minutesSP-ELA912-034

THE GOAL

What students will learn

Students define an unreliable narrator, find clues in a short story that contradict what the narrator says, and explain what most likely happened using evidence from the text.

BEFORE THE BELL

Get ready

Copy the reading and worksheet (pages 3-5) for each student. Write the warm-up question on the board before class.

KEEP THE PLAN CLOSE

Your teacher guide

Teacher directions only. Student worksheets and the answer key are in the complete PDF.

UNRELIABLE NARRATORS: CAN YOU TRUST "THE NIGHT SHIFT"?
Grades 9-12 | 50 minutes | SP-ELA912-034

THE GOAL
Students define an unreliable narrator, find clues in a short story that contradict what the narrator says, and explain what most likely happened using evidence from the text.

BEFORE THE BELL
Copy the reading and worksheet (pages 3-5) for each student. Write the warm-up question on the board before class.
- Student reading (page 3)
- Worksheet (pages 4-5)
- Pencils
- Highlighters (optional)

STEP BY STEP
1. (5 min) Warm-up: Post this question: "Think of a time a friend told a story that made themselves look better than they really were. How could you tell?" Students write two sentences. Ask two volunteers to share without naming anyone.
2. (15 min) Read: Hand out the reading. Read the first paragraph (the definition) aloud. Students then read the story silently and mark each spot where something does not add up with a question mark in the margin.
3. (20 min) Worksheet: Students complete questions 1-11. Questions 1-7 ask about specific clues in the story; questions 8-11 ask students to explain and write.
4. (5 min) Partner check: Pairs compare their question marks from the reading and their answers to questions 3-7. Each pair agrees on the single strongest clue that Dale fell asleep.
5. (5 min) Exit ticket: Students answer the exit ticket at the bottom of the worksheet. Collect everything in one stack.

NOTES FOR YOU
- The story never says outright that Dale fell asleep or lost the money. That is on purpose. Students should prove it with clues, not just state it.
- Some students will feel sorry for Dale. That is a fine reaction and fits question 11. Sympathy and unreliability can go together.
- If students ask, the term "unreliable narrator" was first used by critic Wayne C. Booth in his 1961 book The Rhetoric of Fiction.

EXIT TICKET (read aloud or post)
Write one sentence that Dale says and one sentence explaining what really happened instead.

EARLY FINISHERS
Early finishers rewrite the last paragraph from Mr. Ortiz's point of view in 6-8 sentences, using at least two clues from the story that Dale missed.

PAGES TO COPY: only pages marked STUDENT PAGE in the complete PDF. Answers are on the last teacher page.

READY WHEN YOU ARE

Take the plan with you.

Teacher copy — includes the answer key.

The complete PDF includes welcome pages, substitute directions, student worksheets, and answers. Give students only the worksheet pages. Check the page labels before you print or share.

Download complete teacher PDF

Opens the PDF in a new tab. Use its print controls to select the student pages you need.

Download teacher phone guide

A readable guide that opens offline in your browser. Student worksheets and answers are not included.

Free lesson · SP-ELA912-009Guide ↓PDF ↓

QUICK ANSWERS

In short:

This free 50-minute English sub plan for grades 9-12 teaches unreliable narrators with an original short story, "The Night Shift," told by a clerk who insists his shift went perfectly. Students find clues that contradict him, explain what really happened with text evidence and retell one scene. Answer key included.

Frequently asked questions

What is an unreliable narrator?

An unreliable narrator is a storyteller whose account the reader cannot fully trust. The narrator may lie, misunderstand events, or present themselves too favorably, so readers compare what the narrator says with the details the story shows.

What are famous examples of unreliable narrators?

Common classroom examples include the narrator of Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart," Huck Finn in Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, and Holden Caulfield in J.D. Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye.

Who came up with the term unreliable narrator?

Literary critic Wayne C. Booth introduced the term in his 1961 book The Rhetoric of Fiction.

What grade level is Unreliable Narrators: Can You Trust "The Night Shift"? for?

It is written for grades 9-12 in English Language Arts (English 9-12).

How long does Unreliable Narrators: Can You Trust "The Night Shift"? take?

Plan on about 50 minutes. The teacher guide breaks the period into timed steps a substitute can follow.

What does the substitute need to prepare?

Copy the reading and worksheet (pages 3-5) for each student. Write the warm-up question on the board before class.

Does this lesson need technology?

None. Paper and pencil only.

Is there an answer key?

Yes. The free complete PDF (6 pages) includes substitute directions, the student pages, and a teacher answer key on pages marked TEACHER PAGE.