English Language Arts Creative Writing
Show, Don’t Tell: Rewriting Emotion Statements as Scenes
Students learn four tools for showing emotion instead of naming it, grade a paragraph for telling, and rewrite six flat sentences into mini-scenes that let the reader feel the emotion.
THE GOAL
What students will learn
Students will distinguish telling statements from showing details, identify the four tools of showing (action, body, dialogue, setting), and rewrite flat emotion statements as short scenes.
BEFORE THE BELL
Get ready
Copy the 2-page worksheet (one per student).
KEEP THE PLAN CLOSE
Your teacher guide
Teacher directions only. Student worksheets and the answer key are in the complete PDF.
SubstitutePlans.com
English Language Arts • Creative Writing
SP-CWRIT-009 • Free to print and use in your classroom • substituteplans.com
Show, Don't Tell: Rewriting Emotion Statements as Scenes
English Language Arts • Creative Writing • Grades 8-11 • 45 minutes
Time needed: 45 minutes (one class period)
Prep: Copy the 2-page worksheet (one per student).
Technology: None.
Student independence: High. Individual writing with an optional pair swap.
Copies to make: One 2-page worksheet per student
Materials: Pencils, Worksheet
Goal for today: Students will distinguish telling statements from showing details, identify the four tools of showing (action, body, dialogue, setting), and rewrite flat emotion statements as short scenes.
BEFORE THE BELL
☐ Copy the worksheet, one per student (2 pages).
☐ Write on the board: TELLING names the feeling (She was nervous). SHOWING gives the evidence (She checked the clock for the third time in a minute).
☐ Write the four tools: ACTION, BODY, DIALOGUE, SETTING.
SAY THIS TO START
Here is a rule good writers break on purpose and bad writers break by accident: do not tell the reader the feeling, show the evidence and let the reader feel it. Today you will learn four tools for showing, catch the telling in a paragraph, and rewrite six flat sentences into scenes.
RUN OF SHOW
0–5 min - YOU: Take attendance. Hand out the worksheet and read the two examples on the board.
STUDENTS: Follow along.
5–12 min - YOU: Students read the explanation on page 1. Ask for a volunteer to show "bored" using one of the four tools without saying the word.
STUDENTS: Read; try one example aloud.
12–22 min - YOU: Students complete Part A (find the telling).
STUDENTS: Mark and label telling sentences.
22–40 min - YOU: Students complete Part B (six rewrites). Walk the room; push students who sneak the emotion word back in.
STUDENTS: Rewrite each statement as a mini-scene.
40–44 min - YOU: Optional: pairs swap and guess the emotion behind each rewrite without seeing the original.
STUDENTS: Swap and guess.
44–45 min - YOU: Collect worksheets.
STUDENTS: Hand in the worksheet.
IF THINGS GO WRONG
• If students use the emotion word in the rewrite, circle it and ask them to replace it with one of the four tools.
• If a student says showing takes too many words, agree: it does, and that is why you save it for the moments that matter.
• If a student finishes early, use the early finisher list.
EARLY FINISHERS
• Rewrite the whole Part A paragraph so that it tells nothing and shows everything.
• Pick one rewrite from Part B and extend it to a full page in your notebook.
SUPPORT AND CHALLENGE
• Support: Let students do four of the six rewrites and allow one emotion word in Part A rather than requiring a full rewrite.
• Challenge: Ask students to do each rewrite in Part B with a different one of the four tools, labeling which tool they used.
NOTES FOR THE TEACHER (you fill this in)
How far the class got / what to pick up next:
Students who were especially helpful:
Anything the teacher should know:
The complete PDF has the student worksheet (pages 4-5) and the answer key (page 6).